no continuing city

I retired officially fourteen years ago and moved to Saint Louis, but since that time I’ve continued to work part time at Saint Louis University. I taught basic English classes for a while; then for the past eleven years I have offered a senior honors seminar called Great Books. Somewhere in there I also served as an assistant dean in SLU’s now defunct graduate college. This spring I’ve decided to retire completely, partly because my beloved is retiring and partly because it’s time.

I’ve loved Rilke’s poem, “Herbsttag,” for many years, love the opening especially in English, “It is time, Lord . . . ,” not so much about what it is time for the speaker to do as a proleptic evocation of what God might do, the near casual feeling of those first few words juxtaposed as they are to a set of cosmic expectations couched in rhetorically extravagant flourishes. Clearly this speaker’s autumn reflection means to image a metaphysical autumn, a time of last things, of passage from one life state to another. The poem is widely available. Here it is together with a number of translations.

I share the restlessness of the poem’s concluding lines. I am neither homeless nor friendless, except in the sense of being alone as we all are alone, but I am experiencing at least two contrary emotions as I think about the future. These inspire no new thoughts about death—it’s out there somewhere. Rather, what I am experiencing is a conflict between desiring to do old age as a contest between my body and the set of physical limitations that come with being almost eighty on the one hand, and on the other a contrary desire to take a nap.

Taking a nap has its advantages, I suppose, if one is willing to slide into decline and live with one’s memories. But I remain restless, walking up and down whatever streets I find to walk in, writing late at night, writing trivia, still seeking to overcome it, returning to old forms of thought I had abandoned for years, looking for my ancestors. I wrote a passable sonnet not long ago. I wrote a villanelle, not really good but a villanelle nonetheless. I’d like to write a good one. I may return to rhyme, not a bad spiritual exercise.

I’m describing a state of mind that many readers have found in Tennyson’s “Ulysses,” but that poem’s naïve evocation of the will bespeaks its late romantic origin and the youthful mind of its author. Tennyson was only 24 when he wrote “Ulysses,” a poem more likely to appeal to the youthful Bobby Kennedy (who loved it, as everyone knows, I think) than to someone at my time of life. Still, my restlessness is real, and my own. I need to learn to exploit it rather than merely living with it. I can hear the voice of some learned person reminding me of Ernest Becker, but Becker’s various immortality projects seem to me to belong to youthful thinking as well.

My beloved and I are gearing up for some travel, road trips around our own continent—though we haven’t ruled out travel abroad. I have a long list of projects to complete or cause to be completed at home, some of which must be finished before another winter. I have walks to take, some with camera in hand. I have friends to talk with and books to read, a villanelle to write and potentially a new project to explore closed forms of poetry I abandoned years ago after publishing a set of sonnets I came to dislike. There’s a certain comfort in playing with closed forms and an existential discomfort that goes with writing in open ones. So my closed form project may be a hdege against restlessness.

But I guess I’m trying to school myself to think of old age as an invitation not to design an immortality strategy (pace Becker) but still to live with as much gusto as I can muster for the remaining time I have. I’m aware of my huge good fortune in possessing good health, though I need to take off a few pounds (actually more than a few). So my prescription for myself is contingent upon continued good health and therefore is for myself alone; though you’re welcome to stop by, if you like. We can have a coffee at Mokabes or a beer at The Shaved Duck if it’s late enough in the day, and talk about whatever’s in the air.

I think I may be reconciled to living in the city I have in the here and now, not in another one to come (pace Plato and St. Paul). The academy was in some ways my city to come, to be sought or founded in the realm of discourse. But nobody can really live in such a place, and one thing I may have learned from this perception is that it is the very accidental character of real cities that makes them fit for human habitation, just as it is uncertainty that makes human life bearable and sometimes joyous; though I don’t carry the argument so far as Marilynn Robinson does, arguing from Johathan Edwards that the apparent arbitrariness of the world bespeaks a creator.

My life has also been fortunate in that I’ve never been denied culture, never lacked means or opportunity to refashion myself when I needed to do so. It’s sometimes comforting to think that given the world as it seems I’d live the same life, ask for the same jobs, over again—though I know I wouldn’t. I’ve refashioned myself sufficiently and often enough to be aware that self creation is surrounded by a thick matrix of contingency. A friend used to like to paraphrase Heraclitus ‘You can’t step in the same river even once.’ One isn’t guaranteed the world as it seems, not tomorrow, maybe not even yesterday.

So that one founds oneself in the realm of discourse as the world rushes by—and one is fortunate if the real city one lives in affords hidey holes, places to escape, and lots of unsupervised spaces for play. The real and contingent city is as febrile as a summer street dance, as brief on the wind as a smile and a shoeshine, thick with possibility and empty of information about itself as a week-old newspaper. One dwells in it upon sufferance—I’ll go that far with Robinson, since I know neither the beginning nor the end of the place that passes.

And I guess I’ll continue to write this blog and try to post more regularly than I have recently. There’s more to my restlessness than the common struggle with mortality. Though I’m not sure what the more is I seem to need to propose thought projects I know I’ll never complete.

5 thoughts on “no continuing city

  1. Julian,
    “Retired.” Hmmm. Official or otherwise, retired is a word that has a ring to it doesn’t it? Well, actually more of a thud than a ring. But, “restless.” Now there is a word guide to the future. A nap banisher if there ever was one. Remember the rock band from the 60’s —The Ventures? Remember their version of Chet Atkins “ Walk Don’t Run”? How did those guys know then what we would need now?

    The spirit of Rilke’s, “it is time, Lord…” was I think predated by St. Paul’s words to Timothy. It is as though Paul knew the hour when he urged his young friend, “…come before winter.” Thankfully, restlessness is a good antidote to the obvious.

    Lists are good. Lists that go unfinished are better. The unfinished gives us a place to start each day. And, besides. What are notebooks for? When is a lecture, a poem, a stray insight that shows up like a little kid with his hands in his pockets not rolling around in our heads? Notebooks. Wonderful inventions.

    Now, about the instructions about dropping by. Remember the words of the prophet Jimmy Buffett, “ It is always 5:00 O’clock somewhere.”

    P.S. Rare back and have a good time.
    grace and peace,
    Curtis

  2. Dear Julian,

    I just love what you wrote, it rings so true. and it so so beautifully written.. and at least you finish what you write.. I’ve started many writings that I never get to finish, lack of time and energy, children, and yeah gardening– as soon as that weather warms up, I’m out in that garden.. sowing, weeding, planting, harvesting and talking to the birds and plants while I listen to books I read a long time ago or never got the chance…
    And yes naps and relentlessness –they are not incompatible.. There is so much to discover and to do, that you need to take naps in between.. to rest… I used to sleep very little, go run before kids were up and still do a bunch of stuff when back home until fibromyalgia hit and I HAD to take naps, and spent many days on the couch, I was so so tired, but I got to watch tons of BBC documentary and learned a new hobby, embroidery.. (with the HCT points) couldnot follow any style, and wanted to create my own models, but Mark loved them and framed them.. and I got to spend 4 years close to my chidren.. all in all the bad was good.. but I’m sure glad those even useful long naps are gone!! But sometimes naps are necessary, so enjoy your naps, make them short so you are refresh and can embrace more relentlessness… and as your friend says ‘it’s always 5.00 o’oclock somewhere” well here “it’s always wine o’clock somewhere” especially during the long Summer days when it’s time to sit and contemplate the day and what surrounds us. Next time I enjoy my glass of Rosé while admiring my garden and resting from listening to Bleak House and having talked to my chickens, my cats and the neighbor’s cats coming to visit, well I’ll drink to you, to the health and long life of the wonderful gentleman you are. And if one of those trips takes you abroad, let’s hope it will take you to Alsace where the first Amish settled, here we celebrate Quilting and Gems and Oktober Fest , the wine is fruity and the dialect is Germanic; although we are in France.. As for lists, I make them every day, and yes notebooks, that’s what they are for.. even when you have a gmail calendar. Even if I tend to quickly stray from the “how to be successful” list to the how to the “oh well, that chore will still be here tomorrow, won’t it?’ and sometimes just the plain “what the f***k”. .. there are always things that need to be done before Winter, others during Summer .. and then there is the “live list” the one is not successful and does not get you a perfect house, there is the list that grows so that it looks more like a mindmaps having taking apparently useless turns, turns to take the dog on a longer walk (than planned on the list) with the kids, oops and yes, let’s go to the pool the weather is nice, the house will still be dirty when we get back to it. Oh yes and visiting that exhibit, museum, and castle, that is good for your education kids… ain’t it?? Well guess what since that is tiring for Mama with fibromyalgia, she’s going to take a short power nap and we’re going to go.. (and that ‘s how naps also end up on the list..)

    So as your friend paraphrasing ‘You can’t step in the same river even once.’ .. it is never the same castle, never the same walk with the kids, the same going to the pool and to KFC because mama will be too tired to cook when we get back” … I think I’ll really do my do it lists when I retire… unless grandchildren come to the rescue…. Ooops I realize it was a long reply, talking a bit too much about me, when I wanted to talk about you.. you inspired me, your wanting to retire with that relentlessness and need to take naps,.. Retirement has a ring to it .. as long as it means “not to reitre from life”… so don’t ‘retire’ just yet. I want to read you again…

  3. Julian….that is really excellent and profound. Agree about Robinson. Existential angst. Bring it on. Thanks for sharing.

Comments are closed.