the dead hand

We’re in a strange historical trough at the moment, as the economy gets worse and worse. Laura McKenna, at 11D, fears the CitiGroup crisis is worse than reports have told us, and says “Rumor has it that Citibank is going to go bankrupt.” So as public affairs exhibit all the signs of panic on the one hand, Paul Krugman describes “the emergence of a power vacuum at the height of the crisis” on the other, a vacuum reminiscent of the interregnum between 1932 and 1933 when “the outgoing administration had no credibility, the incoming administration had no authority and the ideological chasm between the two sides was too great to allow concerted action.”

But the present crisis of leadership seems more than an accident of history. While the new administration struggles to be born, the old seems determined to perpetuate itself and do, from my perspective, as much damage as it possibly can while it still holds the reins of power. The Bush team’s promulgation of “midnight regulations” and its shifting of large numbers of its political appointees into high-level civil service positions, a strategy called burrowing in, in order to protect them from being fired and thereby perpetuate their influence, have been the most reported of the outgoing administration’s efforts to thwart the public will–together with speculation that Bush may issue blanket pardons to many of his most vulnerable appointees who have committed crimes during his lawless administration for which somebody might decide to prosecute them. Add to these disturbing developments the present congressional stalemate over aid to the auto industry and Henry Paulson’s foot-dragging over the next stage of the $700b rescue plan, and the trough becomes a slough.

Indeed, across the spectrum of the conservative movement, so-called, there seems to be a determination to continue to defend and perpetuate bankrupt ideology that has been falsified by events and by and large repudiated by the public. Mike Huckabee has a new book entitled Do the Right Thing: Inside the Movement That’s Bringing Common Sense Back to America and is on a tour promoting it, looking every inch like a presidential candidate again. Sarah Palin has been on a victory tour, finding new venues for cognitive dissonance, and wherever she goes she speaks for the old time religion. David Brooks predicts this week that control of the Republican Party will remain with “Traditionalists,” because “Congressional Republicans are predominantly Traditionalists,” and “Traditionalists have the institutions.”

Brooks goes on to argue that conservatism has rigidified into Traditionalist ownership of conservative mythology. Here are a couple of of observations that I think are insightful in that regard.

Members of the conservative Old Guard see themselves as members of a small, heroic movement marching bravely from the Heartland into belly of the liberal elite. In this narrative, anybody who deviates toward the center, who departs from established doctrine, is a coward, and a sellout.

This narrative happens to be mostly bogus at this point. Most professional conservatives are lifelong Washingtonians who live comfortably as organization heads, lobbyists and publicists. Their supposed heroism consists of living inside the large conservative cocoon and telling each other things they already agree with. But this embattled-movement mythology provides a rationale for crushing dissent, purging deviationists and enforcing doctrinal purity.

And bogus or not, this mythology gives its adherents who still hold power in Washington a license to attempt to shape the future in its image even in the face of resounding defeat at the polls.

All the signs seem to point to a pragmatic Obama administration rather than an ideological one. I find this very hopeful. David Sanger predicts that Obama will govern from the center right of his own party, and that is hopeful too. Both Brooks and Sanger are predicting an Obama administration characterized by thoughtfulness and creativity rather than ideology as they survey the choices Obama is advertised to be making for his cabinet and White House staff. As Sanger puts it:

The choices are as revealing of the new president as they are of his appointees — and suggest that, from its first days, an Obama White House will brim with big personalities and far more spirited debate than occurred among the largely like-minded advisers who populated President Bush’s first term.

President Obama will need broad and diverse support if he is to govern effectively. His first moves seem calculated to garner such support and to maintain it in the future; though during its early days in office the new administration will need to do a good deal of house cleaning to disencumber itself from the Bush administration’s last ditch efforts to bind that future.

students arrested for celebrating America

Here’s a letter from the daughter of a friend about her experience last night after the presidential election results were made clear. The daughter is a student at The Eastman School of Music.

“As I watched Barack Obama’s electoral vote count rise beyond 270 at 11:00 pm, tears came to my eyes. Not even an hour later, Obama was speaking to this country as our future President. Some friends were coloring the already dominated blue map or our 50 states and I decided to head home, looking forward to a good night’s sleep, contently anticipating my dreams about what my role would be in order to answer Obama’s call for change. As I was heading to my car, my friend said, “Hey, listen to the music.” As we walked towards the Eastman dorms down Gibbs street, I heard the anthem of our country pouring out of 60 some students and a small band. We cheered and sang, clapping and dancing. I joined hands and cried. I felt the pulse of our patriotic songs like never before. As the band began marching up and down the streets, we all willingly followed. I watched from behind. For the first time, I saw my classmates passionate about something other than music.

“As we headed down Main Street two cop cars pulled up. Students looked around wanting to bolt, searching for protection. A cop told us to be quiet, a “paddy wagon” was on its way, and he had no problem putting all of us in jail. “But we’re celebrating!” one of the players glowed. “If I hear another instrument or shouting of any kind, you’ll all be taken in.” “We’ll just walk then,” I retorted as I stepped past the officer, waiving, urging all to keep moving forward. As the sixty of us tried to remain hush-hush, I heard, “We shall overcome…we have overcome today.” And as we all joined together in song, I couldn’t help but think of my parents. Although they walked out of necessity for the freedoms of all Americans, I walked this night in joy, celebrating those freedoms.

“But we are Eastman music students and regardless of our emotional state we want to make music. So, the guys suggested returning to the Hyatt where the DNC of Rochester was hosting their party. We all marched in, clapping and dancing to the music, entertaining the remaining guests. As we paraded onto the streets, I sensed that not a one of us was considering the threats of the authorities, how could we on such a night! But like a flash, three police cars pulled up, and immediately we saw cops demanding the guys with instruments to sit down on the ground. “And if the rest of you don’t get going, you’ll be arrested too.” As our group quickly dispersed, I walked over to the guys sitting on the pavement…torn. Should I sit or not?? Instead, I walked over and intently gave each of them a hug of gratitude and empathy. With a handful of others, I decided to stand and watch at the corner for an hour and a half as seven police cars arrived. Ten or so officers frisked, cuffed and loaded my friends into a van. As they tossed the instruments into a car, one officer began jingling the tambourine. “Hey! You’re disturbing the peace!” As the police shot glares, we just stood and waited.

“Unlawful assembly was the charge. Apparently a gathering of four or more in the streets without a permit is considered an unauthorized congregation. As I was being told this at the city jail last night, images of city streets all over the country were flashing through my mind. All of America was assembling. All were celebrating. They spent the night in a holding cell because we were not permitted to post their bail for another 3 hours. As I watched 8 of my classmates go through the docket court this morning, all I could think was that they were held for disturbing the peace, when in actuality it was peace we were celebrating.

“I am glad to report that Eastman not only sent a lawyer to represent their students, but Eastman was prepared to post bail. I watched as the Judge and lawyers looked over the charges. As they smirked in disbelief that these students were even picked up, the charges were dropped and my classmates dismissed.

“But, Obama is our President.”